Stats Collection Time Anomaly

Johnathan Lewis (@JLOracle) recently published a short post about Stats Collection Time, talking about the table dba_optstat_operation (and dba_optstat_operation_tasks ), which reminded me about (what I regard as) an anomaly in the output in the NOTES columns in Oracle 12C.

I won’t repeat why it’s useful to check these tables as Johnathans note and @MDWidlakes’s comment here should give you all you need to know.

The DBA_OPTSTAT_OPERATION.NOTES column contains the parameters passed into the DBMS_STATS command, so you know what was done. It also reports the DEFAULT used by the DBMS_STATS job. Well, it does if you call DBMS_STATS explicitly, but the standard overnight auto job just says “default”. Why doesn’t is expand on that the way the explicit call does? If the default was changed between runs, you may end up with very different results but with no indication why. Am I missing something?

The following 2 rows of data show the output from each run. Note that the DEFAULT for METHOD_OPT in this database has been changed from “FOR ALL COLUMNS SIZE AUTO” to “FOR ALL COLUMNS SIZE REPEAT”** but was not explicitly passed-in for either run.

DBMS_STATS.GATHER_SCHEMA_STATS – decodes the DEFAULTs

OPERATION : gather_schema_stats            
TARGET    : MYSCHEMA     
START_TIME: 15-SEP-16 07.04.47 
END_TIME  : 15-SEP-16 07.09.02 
STATUS    : COMPLETED                                   
JOB_NAME  : 
NOTES     : <params>
            <param name="block_sample" val="FALSE"/>
            <param name="cascade" val="NULL"/>
            <param name="concurrent" val="FALSE"/>
            <param name="degree" val="NULL"/>
            <param name="estimate_percent" val="DBMS_STATS.AUTO_SAMPLE_SIZE"/>
            <param name="force" val="FALSE"/>
            <param name="gather_fixed" val="FALSE"/>
            <param name="gather_temp" val="FALSE"/>
            <param name="granularity" val="AUTO"/>
            <param name="method_opt" val="FOR ALL COLUMNS SIZE REPEAT"/>
            <param name="no_invalidate" val="NULL"/>
            <param name="options" val="GATHER"/>
            <param name="ownname" val="MYSCHEMA"/>
            <param name="reporting_mode" val="FALSE"/>
            <param name="statid" val=""/>
            <param name="statown" val=""/>
            <param name="stattab" val=""/>
            <param name="stattype" val="DATA"/>
            </params>

Autotask Overnight Gather – doesn’t decode the DEFAULTs

OPERATION : gather_database_stats (auto)   
TARGET    : AUTO       
START_TIME: 15-SEP-16 22.01.20 
END_TIME  : 15-SEP-16 22.38.40 
STATUS    : COMPLETED            
JOB_NAME  : ORA$AT_OS_OPT_SY_1212  
NOTES     : <params>
            <param name="block_sample" val="FALSE"/>
            <param name="cascade" val="NULL"/>
            <param name="concurrent" val="FALSE"/>
            <param name="degree" val="DEFAULT_DEGREE_VALUE"/>
            <param name="estimate_percent" val="DEFAULT_ESTIMATE_PERCENT"/>
            <param name="granularity" val="DEFAULT_GRANULARITY"/>
            <param name="method_opt" val="DEFAULT_METHOD_OPT"/>
            <param name="no_invalidate" val="DBMS_STATS.AUTO_INVALIDATE"/>
            <param name="reporting_mode" val="FALSE"/>
            <param name="stattype" val="DATA"/>
            </params>

 

**You should control the histograms that you need to maintain your schema stats as you would like Oracle to see them. The Oracle default approach of lots of histograms can be costly to maintain and store, and any stats which use Adaptive Sampling (all prior to 12C, and Height-Balanced / Hybrid in 12C onwards) carry a risk, especially in OLTP systems.
FOR ALL COLUMNS SIZE REPEAT was useful until Oracle12, when a change in the algorithm makes it dangerous, and it should NOT be used.  You should be using GLOBAL_STATS_PREFS and TABLE_STATS_PREFS to control your stats.

 

%d bloggers like this: